I have a boyfriend; a wonderful boyfriend. A wonderful person. A kind, gentle, compassionate, strong, willful, accomplished man.
He has an ex, his most recent ex, who is from all accounts an interesting, intelligent, strong, willful, accomplished woman. They broke up around the same time I broke up with my most recent ex, although our relationships were very different.
For me, when I have lost someone loved, it has always been a sort of comfort to establish a friendship with them that included knowing their new loves, even if it hasn't always been easy... even though it's often painful to see someone I loved and hoped for a long life with having that life with someone else. There is also something valuable, I think, in seeing that loved one live happily with another person who is not only my equal but an even better match for them; someone who I can honestly like and feel not upstaged by, but simply recognize them as a better match. It's harder when I perceive an inequity, for instance if I don't think my ex treats the other person as well as they deserve or vice-versa... but usually it is a good thing, remaining friends with my ex and establishing some rapport with their new love.
In this case, my boyfriend's ex wants to remain friends with him, and for many months had a hard time recognizing the boundaries he set, in a fairly intrusive way. To give her some credit, for the first months of our relationship he didn't know what boundaries he wanted to set, didn't know what he wanted from our relationship, and so she perhaps couldn't clearly perceive the lines most of us know by heart; the lines between lost love and new friendship. So it was difficult.
After a time, though, after about six months of our dating, the lines became clearer; he had definitively chosen a new relationship with me and discarded the potential for rekindling the relationship with her, at this point long-distance by some thousand and a half miles. He said in no uncertain terms, this is where I'm at; this is my new life. Still, she persisted in communicating with him as her lover, not her ex-lover. She would not let go of the old intimacy, and rejected news of me as too painful for her to hear or acknowledge.
He, wanting to honor their former closeness, told her that he wanted to stay in communication, but asked that she acknowledge his new relationship, and acknowledge me; and asked that if she wished to stay in close contact with him that she make some effort to befriend me. She refused.
This is where it gets muddy.
It had been most of a year since they had been together, and in the meantime he had allowed a fairly intimate level of communication. By then, she reasonably felt like they had a reasonable relationship for exes. She is quite young, and this was, and is, her first breakup of a very significant love relationship. So, she was angry that he would ask her to accept us as a package deal should they remain friends... and she refused contact with me. And until then, I had accepted his relationship with her as a package deal, thinking, deliberately, only of furthering our relationship together, and not of how she might still, after six, eight, ten months still be thinking of me as the "other woman".
So it got messy. I got angry. We got angry. I felt heartbroken.
We, he and I, together, got over it.
But she didn't. And she continued to talk to him, via email, obeying limitations we had set, but still not understanding or acknowledging, or perhaps understanding and refusing to acknowledge, how things had shifted; how we had become a package deal.
So, ignoring what he had asked for (that she communicate with me if she wanted a relationship with him) and obeying the technical restrictions he had asked for (that she keep things very surface-level if she would not) she continued to email him, at first infrequently, and then with greater intimacy and frequency. She had been in a car accident but not been hurt. Then, she wondered why she was so attracted to Pisces men (such as him). Then, why had he not answered her question about attraction? Also, by the way, she was coming to Portland.
He ignored her question a second time, and said that it was too bad they couldn't meet but he wouldn't feel comfortable with it unless she was comfortable meeting me as well... to which she responded angrily that she hadn't asked to meet and never wanted to meet me, and he could never suggest it again.
I don't know what I can say about that. To me, it crosses a line; one that has been crossed time and time before. I have left out many, many details, including the one about how I emailed her at his request, and was replied to with "I am his former lover of two years".
I understand that she is younger. But I was young once myself, and this still feels wrong. Her behavior, from a very early time in our relationship, feels wrong. It feels possessive, jealous, and intrusive. She is an ex, and seems to have no concept of how to behave as an ex who wants to develop a friendship. I have left out many of his attempts at setting boundaries, partly because it's all too much to type out and partly because they weren't strong attempts. It's not because I don't think he meant them, but perhaps in part because I don't think he knew what he meant.
And partly because I, like him, don't quite know what to do with people who can't understand and respect changing relationships and changing boundaries.
Even though I myself have been such a person in the past.
Almost four years ago I embarked on a relationship with a man who was separated from his wife. They had had an open relationship and she left him for a man she had been seeing. From his account, she was an abusive partner and a fairly inattentive mother; from my perspective as his lover, both were true, though it's obvious how such a perspective can be skewed. He cared for his children most of the time, as far as I could tell, and his stories of their breakup tended, as such stories will, to depict her as the villain. I was convinced but now I don't know; was she? I will never have the detachment to know.
Two years after they separated, they got back together. Although the sexual component of our relationship had ended months before at his decision, we had become very close friends and I was very much in love with him. When they got back together it was clear to me that I could not continue seeing him even as my friend, because of my intense feelings for him.
A year later I was in love with someone else, and we started hanging out again.